Can an Executor Decide Who Gets What? Navigating the Complexities

When someone passes away, their possessions and assets are left behind, sparking questions about their distribution. An executor, appointed in a will or by the court, plays a crucial role in managing this process. But does this mean they can arbitrarily decide who inherits what? The answer, like many legal matters, is nuanced and depends on specific circumstances.

The Executor's Duty: Upholding the Will

The primary responsibility of an executor is to faithfully execute the wishes of the deceased, as expressed in their last will and testament. This means identifying and distributing assets according to the specific bequests and instructions outlined in the will. They act as a steward, ensuring the deceased's final wishes are carried out with integrity and fairness.

Limited Discretion: Exceptions to the Rule

While the executor cannot deviate from the will's provisions in most cases, there are limited exceptions where some discretion might be involved:

  • Specific bequests of personal effects: If the will provides vague instructions on distributing personal items, the executor might have some leeway in deciding who receives them, considering factors like sentimental value or family dynamics.
  • Contingent bequests: The will might include conditions for receiving certain inheritances, such as reaching a specific age or completing educational goals. The executor might need to determine if these conditions are met before distributing the assets.
  • Debts and taxes: The executor prioritizes settling outstanding debts and taxes before distributing assets. This might involve selling assets or making adjustments to bequests to ensure sufficient funds are available.
  • Pour-over wills and trusts: These instruments can work in conjunction with a will, allowing for more flexibility in asset distribution. The executor might have some discretionary power within the defined parameters of the trust.

Important Caveats: When Discretion Can't Override

It's crucial to understand that even in these scenarios, the executor's discretion is limited. They cannot:

  • Add or remove beneficiaries: The executor cannot include individuals not mentioned in the will or exclude those explicitly named.
  • Change the amount or nature of bequests: They cannot deviate from the specified shares or types of assets assigned to each beneficiary.
  • Act based on personal preferences: Their decisions must be objective and guided by the will's instructions, not their own opinions or biases.

Seeking Guidance: When Uncertainty Arises

If the will is unclear, ambiguous, or contains conflicting provisions, the executor should seek legal guidance to interpret its meaning accurately. Consulting a probate attorney ensures they navigate the process responsibly, minimizing potential disputes amongst beneficiaries.

Beyond the Will: Intestacy and its Implications

If the deceased dies without a valid will, they are considered "intestate." In such cases, state laws dictate how assets are distributed, often prioritizing spouses, children, and other close relatives. However, this process can be complex and may not reflect the deceased's wishes. Having a will ensures greater control over asset distribution and minimizes potential conflict, especially in complex family situations.

Communication and Transparency: Building Trust

Throughout the probate process, the executor should maintain open communication with beneficiaries, keeping them informed of decisions and progress. Transparency fosters trust and reduces the risk of misunderstandings or challenges.


  • An executor's primary role is to execute the deceased's wishes as expressed in the will.
  • Discretionary power is limited and should be exercised cautiously and objectively.
  • Seeking legal guidance is crucial when uncertainties arise.
  • Having a clear and valid will minimizes confusion and potential disputes during estate administration.

When someone passes away, the question of who inherits their assets becomes paramount. In this context, the role of an executor often arises, leading many to wonder: can an executor decide who gets what?

The short answer is generally no. An executor's primary responsibility is to faithfully carry out the wishes of the deceased as outlined in their last will and testament. They act as a responsible steward, ensuring assets are distributed according to the testator's (the person who wrote the will) instructions.

However, navigating inheritance can be complex, and there are situations where the executor may have some decision-making power. Let's delve deeper into the nuances:

When the Will is Clear:

In most cases, the will explicitly specifies who inherits which assets. The executor's role then becomes one of administration and execution. They locate and value assets, pay debts and taxes, and finally distribute the remaining estate to the beneficiaries according to the will's provisions.

When the Will is Unclear or Ambiguous:

Sometimes, the will may lack clarity or contain contradictory clauses. In such cases, the executor may need to interpret the testator's intentions and make decisions based on their best judgment. However, this is not a free-for-all. The executor must still act in good faith and consider factors like the testator's overall wishes and past relationships with beneficiaries. If the ambiguity is significant, seeking legal guidance is crucial to avoid disputes and ensure a fair distribution.

When There is No Will:

If the deceased died intestate (without a will), the distribution of assets follows intestacy laws, which vary by state or jurisdiction. These laws typically prioritize surviving spouses, children, and other close relatives in a predetermined order. The executor or administrator appointed by the court then carries out this distribution based on the legal framework.

Limited Discretionary Power:

Some wills may grant the executor limited discretionary power, allowing them to make certain decisions about specific assets or distribute residuary estate (assets not explicitly bequeathed). This power is usually narrowly defined and must be exercised within the overall framework of the will's intent.

Important Caveats:

It's crucial to remember that an executor cannot override the will's clear instructions. They cannot simply decide to give assets to someone not mentioned in the will, nor can they exclude beneficiaries named in the document. Doing so could lead to legal challenges and potentially invalidate the distribution.

Seeking Legal Counsel:

Executors facing complex situations, ambiguous wills, or potential disputes should seek legal counsel. An attorney can provide guidance on interpreting the will, navigate legal procedures, and ensure a smooth and fair distribution of the estate.

Additional Considerations:

  • Executor's duties: Remember, an executor's primary duty is to uphold the deceased's wishes and manage the estate responsibly. Personal biases or preferences should not influence their decisions.
  • Communication with beneficiaries: Keeping beneficiaries informed throughout the process and explaining decisions clearly can help build trust and avoid misunderstandings.
  • Transparency and accountability: Executors are accountable to the court and beneficiaries for their actions. Maintaining accurate records and transparent communication is key.


While an executor cannot arbitrarily decide who inherits what, they may have some limited decision-making power in specific situations. Understanding the legal framework, the will's content, and the executor's role is crucial for navigating inheritance effectively. If in doubt, seeking legal guidance is always recommended to ensure a smooth and fair distribution of the estate, honoring the deceased's wishes.

Go up

This website uses third-party cookies